In January 2023, I saw my weight had creeped disconcertingly close to the BMI threshold where a man my height moves from “overweight” to “obese”. Setting aside that BMI is a problematic number–and that no one I knew would have called me “obese”–it still got my attention.
So I created a plan for 2023:
- I would restart my weight lifting.
- I would eliminate extra calories.
- I would add a protein supplement.
Restarting the weight lifting was straightforward. I have built a decent home gym over the years and my workout is built around 5 primary lifts: squats, deadlifts, bench presses, seated presses, and bicep curls (because I’m a guy).
The first extra calories I cut were cashews and pecans. I snacked on those pretty much all day every day. I ended that habit (with some hunger pangs) by not buying new bags of either from Costco.
For protein, I chose whey powder, added to the Greek yogurt I eat for breakfast.
The First 30 lbs
By the end of May 2023 I had lost 20 lbs, averaging about 1 lb/week.
By the end of August, I had lost another 10 lbs. Slower, but still moving along. I had to pull old jeans out of the back of the closet, and I switched from XL t-shirts to L.
I was obviously doing something right.
But at the end of September 2023, I had only lost 1 more pound. So I did something stupid.
Proteinmaxxing
If one extra serving of protein daily was doing this much good, another extra serving would do even better! Right?
It seems obvious in retrospect that this choice was unnecessary–and misguided. I was losing weight and at the same time getting stronger. So, no, I didn’t need more protein. But I wanted to try it. I mean, all the influencers were shouting it in chorus! MOAR PROTEIN!!!
So I added another bowl of Greek yogurt + protein powder at the end of my day.
How to Gain Back 15 lbs–With Added Cardio!
For the first couple months, my weight hovered within a pound or two of the September 2023 low. After that, it started ticking up slowly, about 1 pound per month.
After regaining 5 pounds, things again hovered for a while. I recall some minor diet changes in there, trimming off a few extra calories around the margins, but for the most part I didn’t worry about it.
Instead, I deluded myself that the new weight was muscle. Or, at least, you know, some of it was muscle. It had to be muscle. I was getting stronger! Protein is magic!
In late November 2024, I bought a smart watch so I could track my heart rate during workouts, and so I could get an idea of my cardio fitness. After wearing the watch for the month of December, the data was quite clear: my cardio sucked. I had been deluding myself about that too.
Also, by the end of 2024, I was 10 pounds up.
So in January 2025, I dusted off the family’s stationary bike and added 30 minutes of Monday-Friday Schwinning on top of my Monday-Friday weight-lifting.
My weight stayed consistent through the end of July. Then started ticking up again (in spite of M-F Schwinning), peaking in October 2025 at 15 pounds over the low of 2 years before.
At this point, I realized my old jeans were getting tight again. I may have been adding some muscle weight, but that wasn’t the only weight I was adding.
It was time to stop deluding myself. Time to end the experiment in extra-extra protein intake.
Regaining Protein Sanity
First, I got rid of the extra bowl of yogurt + protein in the evenings. Then, after a few months, I started reducing the amount of protein I was adding to my breakfast yogurt.
This decision to reduce my protein supplementing was helped in no small part by the more than 50% increase in the cost of whey powder in the first half 2026.
I also trimmed away a few more calories around the margins of my daily intake. Smaller servings. No second helpings. Nothing drastic. Because I’m less about depriving and more about limiting. I’m not, for example, going to give up chocolate. But I can eat a bit less.
By late summer 2026, I was longer adding any whey powder to my breakfast yogurt. That part of my 2023 Plan was over.
I hesitate to say that the 2 years of extra protein was a complete waste, but … I’m not 100% sure it wasn’t. I certainly didn’t need to regain those 15 pounds just so I could improve my bicep curls. And after spending the last year losing weight and still seeing gains across the board, I can’t help but think I should’ve chosen differently. Ah, well.
Wrapping Up
Since October of 2025 I have dropped over 20 lbs, bring my total weight loss since January 2023 to over 35 lbs. And over that nearly 4 year period I have seen gains in my weight-lifting and improvements in my cardio and general fitness.
Lessons have been learned.
First, if something’s working, don’t fuck with it.
Second, I think I have verified (at least for me), that I don’t need to make drastic changes in my diet. Just pay attention and avoid excess.
And, yes, avoid fads promulgated by influencers and gym bros who are 100% “supplementing” with more than just whey powder and creatine–and almost certainly getting paid to shill.
Since I’m still at a slight calorie deficit, attested to by continuing to lose weight, just slower (about 1 lb/month now), I expect I’ll lose a bit more before the end of 2026. But I know that I will bottom out at some point, maybe even bounce back a pound or two. And that’s where I plan to stay.
The final lesson, I guess, is that there is no end game.
I can’t just hit some target number and go back to how I was eating and exercising before. I don’t want to regain the weight I’ve spent years losing, and I don’t want to give up the gains in strength and cardio I’ve worked hard to achieve. I had to make my life different to get here. To stay here, my life has to remain different.
-David
